Both boxes came with an insert describing the products inside and coupons. The Naturals box had a $3 off a $15 natural beauty purchase coupon and the beauty box had a $3 of $15 beauty and a 20% off women's apparel purchase coupon as well as a $10 coupon code for dermstore.com.
Lets start with the contents of the Naturals Box, which contained 6 products:
SoapBox Argan Shampoo - This is a nice sized 2 oz sample bottle of their shampoo which contains Argan oil, and is listed on the card as a Target Exclusive. I like that it as a very mild clean smell and am looking forward to trying it out. The size of the sample would be enough to decide if it's actually something I would purchase, however when I went to find this shampoo online I couldn't find it anywhere except a travel kit on Target, and it isn't on SoapBox's website. It's difficult to value because of this, but since the travel kit comes with 4 - 2 oz products for $7.99 I'll give it a value of $2.
Skinfix Hand Repair Cream - This is another Target exclusive product and is the 2 oz full size that they sell on the Target website, which is a nice purse size for a hand cream. I liked this one as soon as I tried it because it was unscented and absorbed quickly without being greasy or sticky. It also contains 1% colloidal oatmeal, which is supposed to help with eczema and dermatitis as well as extreme dryness. It is pricey for a small hand cream at $14.99, but I will continue to use it and if I really like it I may still repurchase when it's gone.
Burt's Bees Facial Wipes - I use face wipes daily to remove my makeup before using my cleanser but have never tried the Burt's Bees wipes before. These wipes contain white tea, cucumber, and aloe and I received a nice travel-sized 10 pack. A pack of 30 retails for $5.99, which gives the 10 pack a value of approximately $3.
SheaMoisture Coconut Hibiscus Smoothie - This is a curl conditioning cream for thick curly hair, and while I don't have naturally curly hair I do have thick, somewhat frizzy hair so I'm still curious to give this a try and see how it works for me. I'm hoping it will help fight frizz on the occasional days I let my hair air dry. It smells nice from the coconut and I received the 3.2 oz size which sells for $3.99.
Borghese Age Defying Facial Scrub - This is one of two facial scrubs that were included in the naturals box, and this Borghese one is listed as a Target exclusive. It has a golden shimmer to the cleanser with a nice distribution of the exfoliation beads. The 1 oz sample size I received has a value of $3.80.
Acure Organics Brightening Facial Scrub - This is also an exfoliating cleanser and contains organic sea kelp and French green clay. From testing it on my hand this seems like a rougher exfoliant than the Borghese so I'm a little worried it might be too harsh for my sensitive skin. I will try it out on a small section though and may also try mixing it with my regular cream cleanser to see how that works. The 1 oz sample in my box is worth $2.50.
Overall my Naturals box had an approximate value of $30.28, which is well worth the $5 I paid and I am looking forward to trying out all the products. I would definitely purchase another naturals box if Target offers it again in the future.
Next up is the $10 beauty box which contained 8 products:
Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen - This is a sample size and is listed as a Target exclusive. I'm not typically a fan of pencil liners but when I swatched this I realized it is the creamiest eye pencil I think I've ever used. It is also a very bold black and didn't seem to feather when I swatched it on my hand. I am looking forward to trying this out (but not so much looking forward to sharpening it since it's so soft) and seeing if it stays put as well as a liquid liner. The website doesn't list sizes for the full sized eye pen but I'd estimate the sample is about 1/2 of full size so I'll give it a value of approximately $5.
Revlon HD Lacquer - I received the shade Strawberry Topaz which is a very bright coral pink with golden shimmer throughout. In the container it is a gorgeous color, and one I would love to have in a nail polish. As a lip color I'm not so sure that it will work with my pale skin, but it does seem to have a nice thick, opaque formula. The applicator is also a brush rather than the traditional lip gloss doe foot applicator. This is a full size lip lacquer and the price on Target's website varies a bit by shade, with Strawberry Topaz selling for $7.99.
Clairol Hair Food Moisturizing Hair Mask - This has a pleasant honey apricot fragrance and is paraben and mineral oil free. Since I damaged my hair by coloring it over the summer I've been a big fan of hair masks and deep conditioners to help as the rest of the color grows out so I'm looking forward to trying this. I received a 6.3 oz full size bottle worth $11.99.
L'Oreal Butterfly Inteza Mascara - This is a new mascara for L'Oreal which is similar to their popular Voluminous Butterfly Mascara. I've heard great things about the original Voluminous Butterfly and am curious to try this out because the brush is unlike others I've used before. For now though I'm keeping it in the package as I work through quite a few other opened mascaras I have. Also a full sized product, this mascara retails for $7.99.
CoverGirl Eye Enhancers Kit - This is a quad of shadows and I received Daring Nudes. While I have other Covergirl products I like (their Clump Crusher mascara is pretty much a holy grail product for me) it has been a long time since I had any of their eye shadows. The Daring Nudes set contains 4 shades, a charcoal grey/black, a dark brown, a bronzy lighter brown, and a shimmery cream color. I swatched them without primer and they are decently pigmented and not too powdery. The packaging appears to be an updated new version from the previous blue packaging. The set I received doesn't have an online price listed but some of the other sets are selling for $4.49 so that's the value I'll use for this box.
ChapStick Total Hydration Lip Care - I received this in Sweet Peach, which is a clear balm. It is listed as a Target exclusive but I think that may just be the Sweet Peach version because I've seen these popping up in the drugstores and in various subscription boxes. I'm a lip balm junkie so I am looking forward to trying this. I do wish it contained an SPF, but it claims to moisturize for up to 8 hours so it may end up being good for a night balm. The value of this full sized balm is $2.99.
Laneige Water Sleeping Mask - I am intrigued by the idea of a sleeping mask, though at first glance it seems very similar to just a regular night moisturizer. Also a Target exculsive, it is supposed to be used for deeply moisturizing dry skin so should come in handy for the winter, because while I can get oily around my nose my forhead and sometimes the side of my face get very dry this time of year. This has somewhat of a perfumey scent to me (the website describes it as orange flower, rose, and sandlewood) so I'm worried it may irritate my skin though, so I'll try a small section for a couple of days first before I use this on my whole face. The full size of this mask is $23.00, giving my 0.6 oz sample a value of approximately $5.
Boots No 7 Protect & Perfect Advanced Serum - This serum is a 0.1 oz foil packet but it is the only foil packet in this box so I'm not bothered by it at all. This is supposed to be a hypoallergenic serum which is great because I've had a bad reaction to a serum in the past and am now a bit of wary of them. I haven't seen the consistency of this since I don't want to open the packet until I'm ready to use it, but since a little usually goes a long way with serums I think there should be at least enough for a couple of uses in my sample, which has a value of approximately $2.29.
Overall I calculated a value of $47.74 which falls just shy of the $50 Target said it was, but I think the difference might be in the Covergirl eyeshadow quad because only the price for the older packaging is listed online. Regardless of that though I am very happy with everything that I received in my box and as with the Naturals box would definitely buy other Target beauty boxes in the future. I do wish they would do a subscription service for it like Walmart does with their quarterly beauty box, but if you want to increase your chances of knowing when they go on sale make sure you're checking up on the Nouveau Cheap blog. I've mentioned this blog in other posts but I find out about so many great offers from her posts that I can't recommend it enough.
As usual I opened both of these boxes on my YouTube page so if you're interested in seeing more about them check it out here or I've embedded the video below.